
Barack Obama’s presidential candidacy inspired millions the year before his victory in November. On the 4th, when it became clear that the nation’s first African American president had been elected, many groups had cause for celebration. For veterans of the civil rights movement, it seemed like the final barrier had been cleared. For children from diverse backgrounds, Obama provided hope for their future. The group with most cause for celebration on election night, however, comes not from an underprivileged background nor a place of exclusion but rather from one of the most visible positions in society–the public intellectuals. For them, Obama’s victory and subsequent presidency begs interpretation, requires analysis, and demands synthesis. In a country where slavery existed merely generations ago and our parents can recall a time when African Americans could not eat in the same restaurants as white Americans, go to the same schools, or drink from the same water fountains, President Obama’s ascendancy is the event of a career.
Enter Tim Wise. A prolific author, anti-racist writer, and activist interprets Obama’s election in his latest book, Between Barack and a Hard Place: Racism and White Denial in the Age of Obama. Published by City Lights Publishers in February of 2009, Wise’s book weaves history, contemporary sociology and political developments in the campaign to explain what Obama means for America.
A provocative writer, Wise interprets Obama’s victory through a pessimistic lens, arguing that his win signals neither the end of racism nor the opening of new opportunities for the nation’s historically marginalized groups. Instead, racism made its appearance in the election in a new form, what Wise dubs “Racism 2.0,” in contrast to Racism 1.0, an easily recognizable expression of bigotry.
Racism 1.0, Wise explains, is the “traditional old-fashioned kind, rooted in conscious bigotry and hate…which historically has caused many whites to act toward black folks with suspicion, violence, distrust, fear and anxiety” (24).
In the context of the recent campaign, Racism 2.0 needs further attention. Newer, slicker, Racism 2.0 is characterized by “enlightened exceptionalism,” in which “whites hold the larger black community in low regard and adhere, for instance, to any number of racist stereotypes about African Americans–and yet carve out acceptable space for individuals such as Obama who strike them as different, as exceptions who are not like the rest” (23). Far from being less destructive, Racism 2.0 erects new barriers to achievement for African Americans by removing national consciousness away from very real and enduring structural constraints and toward white self-congratulation, Wise argues.
From income and jobs, housing, education, criminal justice, and healthcare, Wise masterfully demonstrates the continuing disparities between black and white America. He notes the absence of these issues in the Obama-Biden campaign or the attempt to read structural inequalities through a race-free lens called CLASS. At every step, Wise absolves the Obama campaign of responsibility for their less than candid approach to racial issues, saying that campaign strategists confronted the reality of white racism by side-stepping the issue.
Wise’s book is a good antidote to the Zoloft of the Obama campaign, “From one [Obama supporter] we hear that Obama is his pick because he makes white people ‘feel good’ about ourselves. Though the reason for which this Obama supporter values his candidate as the political equivalent of Zoloft…is unclear, venturing an educated guess isn’t an especially duanting task” (85). However, his call to white responsibility should be accompanied by a call to politicians of every color, including Obama, to candidly address issues of race. The “Campaign for Change” decided that white America wasn’t ready for the truth; instead of addressing race issues with respect for the intelligence and moral courage of Americans of every background, the campaign reinforced Racism 2.0. For this, the Obama campaign team needs to be held accountable.
Wise’s book provides welcome relief to the obnoxious self-congratulation that followed Obama’s election to the presidency. His call for white responsibility in demolishing the continuing walls of oppression are similarly worthy of praise. However, his analysis of contemporary racism is neither insightful nor suprising. One wonders how quickly his book will recede into the background before another urging QUICK, DECISIVE ACTION against racism is published. A catchy (if not tacky) title distinguish the book from other informative works on racism. Its brevity (149 pages) allows for a quick review on racism and a solid introduction for people new to the literature.
To purchase Tim Wise’s book, click here







